stonedinaustralia wrote on May 27
th, 2012 at 7:39pm:
SupaRevy wrote on May 27
th, 2012 at 4:52am:
I liked it. A lot. Ambitious. Well-imagined and well-executed. Nice job.
Well I thought it wasn't too bad for what it is, just another example of the "tribute" phenomenon.
You can't say the material isn't any good and they had the voices/vocal styles down. Tho I think "Kurt's" shirt is way too long.
Perhaps I was being a bit too generous, in reaction to all the harsh comments...
It's what you compare it to, isn't it? As usual.
I wasn't comparing it to Nirvana or Winehouse or the Stones...
I was comparing it to an imagined assignment at performing arts school: Do a Stones song in the style of Cobain and Winehouse.
On that basis, I'd still give it a solid A. Can't see how anyone could give it less than an A-
Its like when we get some new Stones music soon. Most will compare it to their favorite Rolling Stones songs ever...
I'll compare it to whatever else I've bought this year.
So sue me. Or pity me. Or whatever. I'm just addicted to being happy, that's all.