andrews27 wrote on Dec 5
th, 2008 at 6:37pm:
ijwthstd wrote on Dec 5
th, 2008 at 6:13pm:
There is plenty of great music out there today, it just takes a bit of effort to find it. Also the way the mind processes and responds to music is possibly biological in nature so once again you are just proving NastyHabits original points that if you think the music of 30 years ago is so much better, it really IS because you are old.
No - just experienced at 49 in ways Nasty isn't at 39. I know what decline is; to know that is to process stimuli sociologically rather than biologically. And I know that the only form of response available to the wits on forum boards is the ad-hominem attack, which is why I closed with that gambit rather than opening with it. Your grand game was?...
I actually rather admire eminem, though I prefer my vituperative psychodrama with a bit of melody behind it, as on Dylan's "Idiot Wind." Makes the murder sing, dunnit? And (speaking of biological processing) ranting over melody permits a nuance of love to enter the song. I don't hear that in Hip-hop, and I don't even hear nuance in mainstream hits today.
It didn't used to take effort, and when it did, the rewards were greater, as in 1970-1985. And isn't effortless enjoyment the point of pop music? One should have to hunt for pop culture, as if for an unsoiled bargain at Goodwill? This hardly a marketplace makes.
It's not a matter anymore of preferring "Strangers in the Night" to "Eight Days a Week." Sorry, but the songs are shit today. And the up-and-comers (Rilo Kiley, Fiery Furnaces, et al) haven't got a patch on, say, REM in their start-up phase.
I've been on an Eminemp3 kick this week and have been jazzed at how well his, um, oeuvre holds up - it delivers laughs and insight into the culture-at-large through the admittedly limited perspective of narcissism that is at the heart of his discourse. As far as the lack of melody in his spite and ire, I don't agree at all. I would cite, say, Renagade, from Jay-Z's Blueprint, on which Mr. M raps like a demon, as melodic infusion into the beat driven id spew. But if you don't hear melody bolstering lyrical murder there, ask yourself (this is a discussion, not a gambit, so your honest response is welcome) if that's the song or your ears.
And I agree with you that Mr. Christgau delivering pronouncements on, say, Vampire Weekend is ridiculous, and that making new releases 'canonical' A plusses in the same sense that Countdown to Ecstasy is an A+ is absurd. The Dean was on it in the 70s and 80s, when popular music was being made for his demographic. My point is that there is a ton of music out there not being pitched to or most importantly made for 39 me or 49 you or 6whatever Rob the C-goo. And pretending that there is still some kind of center from which one can discuss the pop music of 2008 is nuts. I don't think consensus can be made about this stuff and there's not still some kind of "industry" that can deliver a marketplace rather than the crazed chaos of MySpace pages and online downloading free-for-all. Maybe that has to do with a decline in quality of stuff - it can't catch everyone's ear anymore. Or maybe things fall apart and the center can't hold. Or maybe the center was always just an illusion.
Has there ever been a time when the older generation hasn't said "the music of the youth of today is nonsense"? Jazz is an abomination in the face of "serious music", BeBop haters, rock and roll dissers who preferred Mantovani for melody and beauty, Robert Crumb and other Yazoo blues fans railing against the Rolling Stones, Jann Wenner hating on punk, Bob Dylan vs. everybody, Keith Richards vs. rap - this is stuff we should be extremely suspicious of lest we become cranky old men with ossified eardrums. So, yeah, I could list a bunch of personal faves from the last 18 years that for me have some heavy juice and continue to please me when I stick them in the matrix, and I could ultimately admit that none of it will ever be Let It Bleed, but so what? Does that say more about Let It Bleed or me? What the hell is good as MacBeth or Moby Dick? The slope been slipping for centuries, apparently.
Given my druthers I
live at the Goodwill hoping for a big fat stack of unsoiled records, preferably 45s, to come out, because so much of my relevant culture comes through the Goodwill, and hell yeah you got to dig for it, not to mention push some other mofo out the way so you can get to it first. I carry that into my day-to-day, so maybe looking in the alley for my kicks is just what comes natural. I stepped out a long time ago, and will gladly admit to responding to stimuli biologically rather than sociologically. My culture is mine own - if it dovetails with the mass-mind than yee haw, join my party, but I'll keep going my own way for another ten years at least, thanks. Has not served me terribly thus far. To quote Mr. Idiot Wind, "Every inch of pleasure got an edge of pain, pay for your ticket and don't complain."
We fired our canons 'til the barrel melted down, let's grab an alligator and pull another round.