The Continued Babyfication of the NFLtpfan10
Back in the day, when professional football was coming to be, players wore leather helmets and tackled people by their heads. The smiles of the winners were missing some teeth, and that continued ino the dawn of the Super Bowl.
Back in the day of the 60's, the best players were the guys who could 'take you out' on any given play... and I don't mean 'to dinner'.
Back in the day of the 70's, teams like the Oakland Raiders prided themselves on playing dirty. That 'commitment to excelence' is still evident today in Oakland (the banner still hangs up high, and the penelties stack sky high year after year).
Back in the day of the 80's (and into the 90's), QB's were knocked around like crash test dummies. Ask Steve Young, one of the most successful QB's of that era. He suffered multiple concussions during his career, and at least three of them were inflicted by the Dome Patrol.
Thankfully, the league has identified the seriousness of football injuries and their lingering affects. Now, whether or not the new rules implimented to protect the players are justified remains a topic to discuss, but the on-the-field rules are clearly stated and should be followed as such.
And that brings me to my point concerning the punishment slapped on the New Orleans Saints by Roger Godell. The punishment was way too severe.
I understand the point of player safety, and I believe there should be no 'bounty' system in pro sports. But the Saints are being misrepresented on many levels.
The rule clearly broken was the 'pay-for-performance' rule, a rule that every team and man alive has had a brush with. Usually, it's two buddies who bet against each other (in billiards, or bowling, or dating). You know you've worked at a place with a football pool... maybe even a company softball tourny. Hell, I bet mothers wage against each other when their daughters compete for Miss Winchestertonfieldville. The players for the Saints were actually playing the games, so it's admittedly different than some of my examples, but no different from every other team in the league. They all 'pay-for-performance'.
Here's the big difference... the Saints were paying out for 'big hits', 'knockouts', and 'cart-offs'. Sound really bad. The bad part, in my opinion, is actually the 'pay' part and not the 'performance' part.
It is every defensive players job to hit the opposition. Their goal, spoken or not, is to disrupt the play of the offense in every legal way possible. I hate to see injuries on the football field, but I love to see that punt returner get his bell rung on one attempt, and then on the next attempt, muff the punt due to happy feet and wandering eyes.
There is not a defensive coach in this league who is teaching their players to tackle with kindness. "If you manage to get past the offensive line, and you have a clear shot at the QB, dance with him awhile and then take him to a movie." Fire that guy immediately.
The truth is - the Saints have not collected on these 'bounties'. Kurt Warner was knocked out during the Divisional Playoff game in 2009. It was a legal hit, and everyone knows it. Now, if Bobby McCray recieved money for that play from his teammates, it is a payment for performance not provided by the league... really similar to a QB rewarding his offensive linemen with watches or vacations when he makes the Pro Bowl.
Oh, yeah... the injury part.
If the Saints are to be penalized so severely for 'pay-for-perormance' because of the intent to injure, then guys like James Harrison, Albert Haynesworth, and Ndomakong Suh should be fined for life. And let's not forget the great players of 'back in the day'... guys like the Hammer, and Steve Atwater, and Ronnie Lott. Headhunters to say the least.
And what about Lawrence Taylor... he broke Joe Theisman's leg on national tv and ended his career. Criminal behavior? No... the diffence is the Saints players bet their own money, while those other guys simply received their check from the league every week.
'Bounty Gate' is reported as an issue about injuries, but, in my opinion, it is really about the money and not about the intent to injure. No one is on that football field with the intent to go to the drive-in.
http://www.nola.com/saints/app/422295/the-continued-babyfication-of-the-nfl.html