|
Pdog
|
Re: Obama elected President
Reply #6733 - Aug 7th, 2009 at 6:12pm
Austin, TX... Oak Hill Gazette, as local a newspaper as you can get for me... FYI, I live in a very conservative area. Most my neighbors are Republicans.
Local protest gains national notoriety
Editor's note: This event became national news. A Gazette reporter was there to witness an unruly hollering mob of people disrupt the meeting and personally insult Congressman Doggett. Conservative cable news and talk radio stations around the country hailed the event as a spontaneous outbreak of opposition to proposed healthcare reform. But it was later discovered that the Travis County Republican Party Chair had led an organizing effort to disrupt the event, and national news services reported that a group called FreedomWorks Foundation had distributed talking points guiding organized disruptions of similar events in other parts of the country. The group is led by former House Majority Leader Dick Armey, a Texan from Flower Mound.
OAK HILL - Congressman Lloyd Doggett (D–TX) has held routine "Neighborhood Office Hours" over the past 15 years – but he said Saturday's office hours were a far cry from last year's casual meet and greet held at the same location.
Held at the Brodie and Slaughter Lane Randall's, Doggett's event was cut short because of the increasingly boisterous crowd that ultimately chased the congressman down the parking lot and mobbed his assistant's pick-up car. As Doggett drove away nearly 35 minutes before the event was slated to end, the crowd cheered and burst into applause.
"It was different from anything I've had in 15 years of doing these," Doggett said. "I don't think that enough people in South Austin or any other part of the county understand how fanatic some of these people are." Doggett represents District 25, which includes most of Southwest Austin.
And by "different" he probably meant the crowd's chants of "just say no," or a poster which literally demonized him by adding devil horns to his photo. Or another poster that featured a marble tombstone with Doggett's name on it.
Doggett attributed this anomaly to Libertarian and Republican party efforts, which he said pulled people in to attend his office hours to create the appearance that Southwest Austin didn't support healthcare reform. About half of the screaming people weren't even from the area, he said, and some hailed from as far away as Williamson County and even Hallettsville.
"They didn't exactly come to have an honest dialogue," Doggett said. "They came basically to demonize instead of to discuss. And so that's unfortunate but, you know, it's their right to protest."
Before Saturday's event, Travis County Republican Party Chair Rosemary Edwards called for organized opposition to Doggett's event from what she later called her "Warriors for Liberty." Her blog, tcrp-redrose.blogspot.com, contains a post from Friday encouraging readers and "all Patriot friends to SHOW UP, STAND UP and SPEAK UP!" and to "BE LOUD!"
She continued: "Make your signs so that they are easily read from afar and USE YOUR CREATIVITY! Come have FUN with us expressing our Constitutionally protected right of public expression of our views." Edwards could not be reached for comment.
The official Twitter account for the Republican Party of Texas, @RepPartyofTexas, has denied any involvement in organizing the protest.
"Rep. Doggett says we organized his Austin greeting," they tweeted. "We didn't. If he can't get this right, why should we trust him with our health care?" The statement did not mention the organizing efforts of the party's county chair.
The Travis County Libertarian Party also disputed their involvement in a press release and called for a public apology from Doggett "for his outrageous remark."
"The TCLP had nothing to do with this event," TCLP Chair Rock Howard said. "Our organization did not encourage our members to attend the event, much less to silence others. To the best of my knowledge, our state and national parties were not involved either." But blogs connected to the Libertarian Party and Congressman Ron Paul did call for an organized protest before the event took place.
William Edwards, a self-identified Republican protester at Saturday's office hours, said this was his first ever demonstration. Edwards said he chose to come mainly because it was close to his house. He has health insurance through his job and he's "happy with that."
He added: "I don't want anybody to change it. It's a very good system. And they talk about the poor people not having insurance – that's baloney." Over the din of the crowd's cries, he went on to tell about an unemployed friend of his in San Antonio who went years without healthcare. Edwards contends his friend's hospital had some of the newest equipment available. He didn't explain how his friend was able to afford access to the hospital's services.
"So don't give me this stuff about poor people not having insurance; that's another lie [the Democrats] like to tell so they can get in power," he added. "I'm a personal witness to that."
Congressman Doggett stressed that opponents of healthcare reform are also the opponents of Social Security and Medicare, which he said have worked "very successfully."
He added: "Near the beginning of the session…because they were holding up all these Tenth Amendment signs, I was saying, ‘Well, if that's your attitude about health care, then I suppose you don't really support Social Security and Medicare,'" Doggett said. "And they said, ‘Yes, we don't. We don't think they're good.'"
At which point, Doggett said, it becomes more than just a healthcare issue.
"I just think this fanatical insistence on repealing Social Security and Medicare is not just about halting the healthcare bill that's up there, but it's about rolling back about 75 years of progress."
The congressman said he changed his usual office hours format in response to the crowd because "there was so much noise, we weren't getting anywhere." He tried to move near the entrance of Randall's to speak with someone when the crowd - "or mob as you might call it" - followed him, blocked the store entrance and chanted "just say no" at the top of their lungs.
"It was apparent that I could not conduct the normal office hours, so I walked out to the parking lot to depart and some of the same crowd decided to try to block my departure," Doggett said. It took many attempts and meetings in his staff assistant Leann's black Honda before the congressman could actually leave in the getaway car.
"You know, I had a woman there saying, ‘If she touches me with that car, it'll be aggravated assault,'" Doggett said. "It was that sort of silliness."
Some of that mob went on to follow Doggett to Bastrop, where he had two other scheduled appearances Saturday. He said those people tried to interrupt his first meeting that was unrelated to healthcare. And at Doggett's second meeting, Bastrop Police had to escort a couple of people out "because they just insisted on yelling and disrupting that meeting."
Doggett said he doesn't anticipate rescheduling Saturday's office hours. He did say, however, that he would explore other ways to reach out to people.
"I really want to know what folks in the Oak Hill area are thinking about this," Doggett said. "I know they've received a lot of misinformation through some of these cable TV and hate radio shows."
Saturday's ordeal may go down as somewhat unsuccessful in Doggett's book, but he said the experience was a learning opportunity.
"It's unsuccessful not so much for me but for people who had a concern, an issue they wanted to raise with me and were denied that opportunity," he said. "I suppose from my standpoint, it was a very constructive session in that there are some people who are so convinced, so ideologically convinced, that they will stop at almost nothing to try to prevent it."
As a result, the congressman said he's more committed than ever to win the approval of a bill that offers more individual choices to access healthcare.
"Much of what this bill is about is not just about folks who don't have insurance, but folks who do and find that it covers less and costs more every year," Doggett said. "I know there are a lot of folks out there…that maybe work for a small business that can't provide coverage, or work for a large business that does and want to go start their own business, or want to switch to a different, more meaningful job - and they can't do it because they're afraid they'll get caught up, say, in pre-existing conditions. They won't have any insurance. And that's what we're trying to do something about."
The bill Doggett helped write, HR-3200, is not about a government takeover, he said. He intends to focus more on the insurance corporations.
"It's trying to prevent the takeover that has occurred from giant insurance companies; to ensure more competition among them and to give individuals who don't have health insurance a way to get it – and for all people to have more choice in insurance companies," he said. "So the insurance giants have good reason to oppose this bill because they're gonna have to change their way of doing business."
Doggett said the Medicare-type component of the bill will be used by about four percent of the under-65 population, and that 96 percent will use a more accessible private health insurance.
"But there's not a small business or an uninsured individual - or really an insured individual - in the Oak Hill area who will not gain from this bill." - Oak Hill Gazette
Reader Opinions George B. AUG 06 • I am more concerned about these protesters who become violent and agitated over "the stupid" things. These are the same types who were unconditionally for Sarah Palin as VP candidate.
I am a lifelong Republican. I like Congressman Doggett and agree with him 90% of the time re: his actions and decisions.
I don't like the health care plan as is. But I don't like these protesters even more.
These people still protest the absurd, like whether Obama is a legal U.S. citizen. Get over it! He is!!!
If Obama were not, wouldn't the GOP confront that issue publicly? They voted on it and ALL of the GOP lawmakers voted that Obama is indeed a U.S. citizen based on his birth certificate and other information.
These protested are just idiots who highlight the "Dumbing-Down of America" that author Peter Stern and several others have written about. Gracie AUG 05 • Let's see. First they told us that if we only knew what that proposed health bill said, we'd all be against it. Then they come to places like Austin where our elected representative tries to discuss this proposed bill, and they refuse to let anyone hear about the bill. Hmm. Lloyd Doggett is an intelligent, honest, wonderful representative. Never in Austin would he be greeted by this rudeness and such meanness. This was the work of organized people who do not want others to hear something they don't like. Where's the freedom these people claim to support? Why can't people discuss with their elected reps proposed bills? What are they so afraid of? Mary AUG 05 • My parents were lifelong conservative Republicans, and they would have been appalled at the behavior of the Republicans at the Doggett event. They could not have fathomed such a thing. My good West Texas mother would have summed it up - "They have no class." Kathleen AUG 05 • I want to thank Rep. Doggett for standing firm and vowing to redouble his efforts to bring our country the health care reform we so desperately need. I was at the event on Saturday and can only describe the behavior of the protesters as crazed. Clearly none of them had any idea what is actually in the proposals being considered in Washington. I know the Republicans organized the protest, but I can't imagine what kind of psychosis accounts for people agreeing to so graphically demonstrate their own ignorance and mental instability. Bill Patton AUG 05 • Your healthcare decisions already ARE being made by government bureaucrats, have been for years – Medicare and Veteran's Administration healthcare. By all accounts they are doing a much better job of it than the insurance company bureaucrats I deal with who charge me for covering something, then come back and tell me they'll only cover a certain percentage of the cost! Please Mr. President, give me freedom from the tyranny of gouging, rip-off insurance companies! Scott W. AUG 05 • We The People don't want our healthcare decisions made by beaurocrats in Washington, regardless who is running the government. It's not about Right vs. Left, it's about tyranny vs. freedom. WE CHOOSE FREEDOM! We will not be ignored any longer! DJ Melton AUG 05 • It sounds as though the protestors weren't there to facilitate a conversation and to get their points across. Rather, they were there to prevent civilized discourse. Bullies typically do want to drown out other people's voices. This would have been abuse if it were one person trying to prevent someone from speaking to others or from moving freely, and it's even more abusive when it's an ugly mob performing those actions. The organizers of this protest should be thoroughly ashamed of the results of their actions. Their actions are more consistent with fascism than with democracy. Brad AUG 05 • Great coverage as opposed to the Statesman. I was there and you nailed it! Zachary Thacks AUG 04 • Doggett digs Kool-aid Norman AUG 04 • 1. We really miss the Dick/Bush years when the world loved the US because of its intelligent leaders/policies: we had Tom Delay as an honost legislative leader, A. Gonzales was an honest public defendant, god and terror were national policies, there were dictators like Syrian Assad and liberators like Musharaf; we had to go up and down with red/orange alerts, Brownie was doing a good job, the GOP was pro-environment, promoted profits through hard work rather than monopoly of power, we had wars of freedom in Iraq and wanted to invade others, attention was paid to 70% of the voters and the intelligent people (not the mentally ill) were on talk shows, and hard working banks were paid nearly one trillion $ to stimulate the economy through bonuses to the CEOs and god knows what other goodies... 2. Now Dems. want bail outs for the common folks through creating jobs by innovative energy mechanisms, improving the economy and environment via cash for clunkers, mortgage subsidies to those who were given honost morgtage terms, improve the US image around the world through rational, logical policies, and have people on the spotlight who can talk coherent sentences. What a shame that they even want health care for those who are squeezed from all sides and have to make choices between food or utilities/rent. GOP! Be an adult. Shut up until next election. If Dems. screw up, they will be dust like you! You can not fool all the people all the time!
|