ROCKS OFF - The Rolling Stones Message Board | |
http://rocksoff.org/cgi-bin/messageboard/YaBB.pl
GENERAL >> MAIN BOARD >> Stones records ranked? http://rocksoff.org/cgi-bin/messageboard/YaBB.pl?num=1519999792 Message started by BrianRollingJones on Mar 2nd, 2018 at 8:09am |
Title: Stones records ranked? Post by BrianRollingJones on Mar 2nd, 2018 at 8:09am
Rank the Stones albums in order from your favorite to least
Beggar's Banquet Aftermath Let it Bleed Their Satanic Majesties Request Out of Our Heads (UK) Sticky Fingers Goat's Head Soup It's Only Rock N' Roll Undercover Emotional Rescue Exile on Main St Tattoo You Some Girls England's Newest Hitmakers Between the Buttons 12 x 5 Dirty Work Black and Blue Steel Wheels Rolling Stones No. 2 Some Girls Rolling Stones Now! Voodoo Lounge A Bigger Bang Bridges to Babylon Blue and Lonesome |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by Paranoid Android on Mar 2nd, 2018 at 11:45am
Since I requested all to play the singles survey a few weeks ago...I will play...but I cant do all of these albums...
Top Six (in some sense of order): Goats Head Soup Beggers Banquet Emotional Rescue Undercover Let It Bleed Black & blue Top of The Bottom: Dirty Works Bigger Bang Their Satanic... Steel Wheels Thats all I got...Do I win anything?? |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by Gazza on Mar 2nd, 2018 at 1:23pm
1. Exile
2. Some Girls 3. Sticky Fingers 4. Beggars Banquet 5. Let It Bleed 6. Tattoo You 7. The Rolling Stones 8. Aftermath 9. Bridges To Babylon 10. IORR 11. Out of Our Heads 12. Blue and Lonesome 13. The Rolling Stones No.2 14. Goats Head Soup 15. A Bigger Bang 16. Voodoo Lounge 17. Undercover 18. Steel Wheels 19. Between The Buttons 20. Emotional Rescue 21. Black and Blue 22. Satanic Majesties 23. Dirty Work Think thats 'em all. Only counting the UK releases. Not these weird early US versions with similar track listings. The top 6 never changes. The order of #2 & #3 sometimes changes depending on my mood, but 'Some Girls' probably gets the nod for sentimental reasons as it was the album that got me into them in a big way. The bottom five is pretty constant too. The middle part of that list could vary widely. 'Blue and Lonesome' is the Stones' worst ever album? Really? I think you're the first Stones fan I've met who didnt like it. :-/ |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by andrews27 on Mar 4th, 2018 at 6:56am
A Bigger Bang above Between The Buttons, Black and Blue, Emotional Rescue, and even Dirty Work?
A Bigger Bang is like the worst Morrissey solo album. When they force out material, they're lucky to come out on the good side of bad: Satanic Majesties', Undercover. On ABB the luck ran out. Their career nadir. |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by Joey on Mar 4th, 2018 at 10:48am
1. Sticky Fingers
2. Some Girls 3. Exile 4. Goats Head Soup 5. Let It Bleed 6. Tattoo You 7. Steel Wheels 8. Emotional Rescue 9. Bridges To Babylon 10. IORR ************************** Still Remember this one blaring over the 1989 August Poolside Stereo System --- Girls Dancing , Sun Blazing , Sinsemilla , Hydro , Purple Haze , Maui Wowie , Coolers full of beer ( Actually , we could only afford domestic beers at that time --- Specialty Beers and Imports were too damn expensive for THIS young Joeykins ............ now a Budweiser tastes like friggin water --- BLECH !!!!! ) , Tan Lines , Suntan Oil glistening off those young nubile bodies , Breasts Heaving , Young Women's Asses so firm one could / did bounce quarters off of their cheeks , Landing Strips ( 1/2 Wolf Puss ) , Ellie Mondale ................... GREAT TIMES : https://youtu.be/LLbzc8eQNl8 Dirty Martini ANYONE ? ! ! :) |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by BrianRollingJones on Mar 4th, 2018 at 11:24am andrews27 wrote on Mar 4th, 2018 at 6:56am:
I don't even think Satanic is bad at all. If you remove the Sing This All Together (See What Happens) song you have a pretty solid album. An album with songs like Citadel, 2000 Light Years from Home, She's A Rain and The Lantern ain't a bad record. They should've tacked on the Dandelion and We Love You singles and trimmed Gomper a bit. It'd be one of the best of 67 if they did that. |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by Steel Wheels on Mar 5th, 2018 at 6:38am
Long ago I gave up trying to rank their records.
With that said, here's what I've been listening to over the past few weeks: Blue and Lonesome Undercover Right now those are my favorite two! |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by andrews27 on Mar 6th, 2018 at 9:40am BrianRollingJones wrote on Mar 4th, 2018 at 11:24am:
Obviously there are at least two great songs on Satanic Majesties', and at least one on Undercover. What they share with ABB is that they sound forced-out, trying too hard to capture a style or fulfill a contract. A lot of albums by a lot of people have been forced out, but the trick is to not let the audience hear it. I would never slag the best songs on Satanic Majesties', and Citadel is a portrait of where it could have gone if they weren't trying to beat the Beatles to modernity. Citadel should have been the first song on an inspired album. |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by Gazza on Mar 6th, 2018 at 6:18pm
No need to overanalyse whether its 'forced' or not. Either you like the songs or you dont.
Theres some utter turds on ABB and some really juvenile lyrics, but theres a lot of solid songs on it too and one or two gems. 'Dangerous Beauty' is a terrific song that ticks all the boxes for me. Topical and humourous lyrics, thunderous drums and the best riff on any Stones record in over two decades. |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by Paranoid Android on Mar 6th, 2018 at 6:42pm Gazza wrote on Mar 6th, 2018 at 6:18pm:
Thats kinda funny...I too liked the song...but actually thought the topical lyrics were rather forced...as well as Jaggers gasps at the end of every line (I just listened to it)...if I didnt know the song was about that Female Marine...I wouldn't have cared about the "forced" part... |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by gimmekeef on Mar 8th, 2018 at 12:55pm
Let it Bleed (it has Gimme Shelter and Rambler ffs)
Exile Sticky Some Girls Aftermath Ya Ya's (tough shit I'm adding it) Decembers Children 12x5 Then the clunkers for me: Satanic Dirty Work Undercover |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by Some Guy on Mar 8th, 2018 at 5:24pm gimmekeef wrote on Mar 8th, 2018 at 12:55pm:
Did we ever get your stance on Emotional Rescue? |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by andrews27 on Mar 9th, 2018 at 8:12am
'Dangerous Beauty' is a terrific song that ticks all the boxes for me. Topical and humourous lyrics, thunderous drums and the best riff on any Stones record in over two decades.
Ugh. We're fortunate that their lyrics didn't take a literal turn like this in the late sixties. The riff -like too many on ABB - is so generic and impersonal that the song couldn't be used as a successful Stones cover by a bar band. On riffs alone - much less as an exhibition of talent - there's no way ABB can be rated higher than Between the Buttons. "My Obsession," "Complicated" and "Miss Amanda Jones" are non-hit deep cuts with unforgettable riffs, even if one is copped from Chuck Berry.. ABB was wrought by the mind that gave us "Back to Zero" and "Winning Ugly." It's up there on the dissatisfaction scale with Dylan's Under the Red Sky. |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by gimmekeef on Mar 9th, 2018 at 3:00pm Some Guy wrote on Mar 8th, 2018 at 5:24pm:
Hated the disco era Title song...loved Dance....and Send it to me......always though that would have been a good live one. Middle of the road album for me knocked down a notch by the cringe worth Arab charger bs |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by YoungPoliceman on Mar 26th, 2018 at 10:03am
1 - Exile
2 - Sticky Fingers 3 - Some Girls 4 - Beggars Banquet 5 - Hitmakers 6 - Black & Blue 7 - Let It Bleed 8 - Goats Head Soup 9 - Between The Buttons 10 - Tattoo You 11 - Aftermath 12 - IORR 13 - Bridges To Babylon 14 - No 2 15 - Undercover 16 - Satanic Majetsy 17 - Out Of Our Heads 18 - Now 19 - Emotional Rescue 20 - Steel Wheels 21 - A Bigger Bang 22 - Dirty Work 23 - Voodoo Lounge Do I really prefer #9 over #11? Not really. It's not until you get to around #20 that I actually see a few albums I don't like all that much. |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by Sleepy City on Nov 16th, 2022 at 1:39pm
Top 10:
Between The Buttons Aftermath Got Live If You Want It! Out Of Our Heads (UK) Their Satanic Majesties Request Beggar's Banquet Let It Bleed Get Yer Ya Ya's Out! Sticky Fingers Rolling Stones No. 2 Bottom 6: Undercover Dirty Work Voodoo Lounge Bridges To Babylon A Bigger Bang Emotional Rescue Best compilation: Flowers Some "classic" albums (Exile, Some Girls, Black & Blue) I find a bit so-so... my fave post '71 studio album is probably Tattoo You. |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by Voodoo Chile in Wonderland on Nov 16th, 2022 at 2:42pm
Great selection, not the typical with all Jimmy Miller produced albums on top top
Got Live If You Want It! it's not in my list, but the fact that was the only "live" album with Brian it's special to me. Charlie Is My Darling is good but not exactly an album, and "On Air" are not tour shows Hope some day they release some live material from the 1967 tour |
Title: Re: Stones records ranked? Post by Sleepy City on Nov 16th, 2022 at 2:58pm Voodoo Chile in Wonderland wrote on Nov 16th, 2022 at 2:42pm:
'On Air' is wonderful, but as I'd already heard everything on bootlegs for years it didn't have the impact it perhaps should've done. Those Paris shows from 65/66/67 deserve a deluxe CD release. |
ROCKS OFF - The Rolling Stones Message Board » Powered by YaBB 2.5.2! YaBB Forum Software © 2000-2024. All Rights Reserved. |