What say you?
I'm going new stuff

A Bigger Bang.

I rate the bonus disc highly, but it lacks the magic of a genuine Stones LP. A Bigger Bang was no masterpiece, but in hindsight, there are some very strong numbesr featured - 'Rain Fall Down' being the pick of the bunch, IMO.

I'll say this: Having Mick finish 40-year-old songs is the only way he can actually get Keith to co-write anymore :)

Rim!

But wait, ABB was the longest album since Exile and the bonus disc is only 40 minutes.  

guest voting allowed.

There's no comparison:

ABBA!


Although, on second thought, those swedish people didn't write Streets Of Love.

A Bigger Bang by far. It's hard to rate this bonus disc of outtakes alongside a studio release. I alos have stated on this messageboard time and time again that I feel A Bigger bang is brilliant so that is the easy winner in my book.

ABB brilliant ?! There is nothing brilliant about it, the songwriting is average, with Rain Fall Down and Brilliant Mistake possibly standing out, but the worst part is the playing, really beneath them, mostly by Keith's fault I reckon, not a decent guitart part in view. At least the bonus disc doesn't have these problems.

PUH-LEEZE!!!

Reissue by a eight lengths!!

Can't stand Bang, biggest let-down in my record collection. To compare it with Exile, even Exile's bonus tracks, is like comparing a drawing of my neighbours retarded 47-year old son with the Mona Lisa.

Teiz wrote on May 22^nd, 2010 at 5:45pm:

Can't stand Bang, biggest let-down in my record collection. To compare it with Exile, even Exile's bonus tracks, is like comparing a drawing of my neighbours retarded 47-year old son with the Mona Lisa.

Have you ever seen The Mona Lisa up close? Talk about a disappointment!

Bonus disc rocks- threw it on at a get together and it jammed nicely!

Holden wrote on May 23^rd, 2010 at 6:36am:

Teiz wrote on May 22nd, 2010 at 5:45pm: Can't stand Bang, biggest let-down in my record collection. To compare it with Exile, even Exile's bonus tracks, is like comparing a drawing of my neighbours retarded 47-year old son with the Mona Lisa. Have you ever seen The Mona Lisa up close? Talk about a disappointment!

They dont allow you close enough to be disappointed!!